In an announcement that didn't come without it's fair share of local criticism, Warsaw's Brylee Brewster was the lone representative for the Ladycats on All-State rosters when they were released last week.
Brewster landed on the first team, very deservedly so, just as she has for the past two seasons after being a second team selection her freshman year.
However, the lack of any of her teammates from a state championship squad joining Brewster on either the first or second teams came with plenty of ridicule on the streets of the county seat and as well as public social media platforms.
Below are complete rosters for this year's 2025 MSHSAA Class 2 Spring Softball All-State honors.
1st Team
Pitcher: Brylee Brewster, Sr, Warsaw; Taelyn Reeder, So, Diamond; Makenna Shockley, Jr, Skyline; Emily Schubert, So, Mount Vernon
Catcher: Rae Downing, Sr, Mount Vernon; Kaydence Cosby, Sr, Central (Park Hills); Maylee Merrill, So, West County; Rachel Nunez, Jr, Miller (At-Large)
Infield: Sydney Miles, Sr, Central (Park Hills); Molly Daniels, Sr, Mount Vernon; Luren Turner, Sr, Diamond; Kylie Walker, Sr, Senath; Breanna Johnson, Fr, Skyline; Gracie Abercrombie, Jr, Stockton
Outfield: Cheyenne Bieber, Sr, Mount Vernon; Mariah Loya, Sr, Malden; Lacey LaMarr, Jr, West County; Raelyn Henderson, Jr, Stockton
UT/DP: Handley McAtee, Sr, Kennett
2nd Team
Pitcher: Abby Gingrey, So, Clearwater; Hunter Shrunk, Jr, Ava; Grace Barton, Sr, West County; Leah White, Jr, Buffalo; McKenzie Morris, Fr, Thayer
Catcher: Brooke Daniels, Sr, Fair Grove; Carsyn Cohen, So, Malden; (T) Chloe Staffen, Sr, St. Genevieve; (T) McKenna Coonts, Jr, Ava
Infield: Shayla Haddock, Jr, Fair Grove; Jorja Eaton, Sr, Clearwater; Laura Kate Johnson, Jr, New Madrid County Central; Paris Henry, Sr, Ava; Grace Lynch, So, West County; Makinley Aaron, Sr, Houston; Taryn Stuhlsatz, Jr, Springfield Catholic (At-Large)
Outfield: Baylee Wilcut, Jr, Kennett; Hannah Forrest, Sr, Ava; Zoe White, Sr, Forsyth
UT/DP: (T) Dalyce Scrivener, Jr, Strafford; (T) Tymber Pinon, Jr, Skyline
(T) = Tie
